50% OFF SALE ON BOXED SWEETS AND BOXED CHRISTMAS CARDS!

20% OFF SALE ON COMMUNION SKU 990 AND CONFIRMATION SKU 922 ITEMS THROUGH 5/31/25

While the Gift Shop is closed to in-person shopping, if you are local and would like to pick up your purchase, select In-Store Pickup.

Orders can be picked up at the reception desk Monday through Friday from 9-4 and Saturday from 9-11 and 2-4.

If you don't see something you want, let us know. If we have it in the store, it can be added to the website.

  1. Home
  2. Baptism and Children's Gifts
  3. Stuffed Toys

Baptism and Children's Gifts

Sort by:
ST MAXIMILIAN KOLBE HOLY BEAR
ST MAXIMILIAN KOLBE HOLY BEAR
$ 15.99
{ "id":6719074435139, "title":"ST MAXIMILIAN KOLBE HOLY BEAR","handle":"st-maximilian-kolbe-holy-bear", "description":"Stuffed blue and white bear shows an embroidered picture of St. Maximilian Kolbe. He has the concentration camp jackets and the two crowns. The back of the bear is embroidered with a picture of the back side of the Miraculous Medal with M I.", "published_at":"2022-08-11T17:08:39", "created_at":"2022-08-11T17:08:39", "vendor":"Holy Bears, Inc.", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Maximilian Kolbe","Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":1599, "price_min":1599, "price_max":1599, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[40122747093059], "variants":[{ "id":40122747093059, "product_id":6719074435139, "product_handle":"st-maximilian-kolbe-holy-bear", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"996-0019", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"ST MAXIMILIAN KOLBE HOLY BEAR - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":1599, "weight":150, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":89, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":89, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":""}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/996-00191.jpg?v=1661532948","\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/996-00192.jpg?v=1661532962"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/996-00191.jpg?v=1661532948", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/st-maximilian-kolbe-holy-bear" }
ST MAXIMILIAN KOLBE HOLY BEAR

ST MAXIMILIAN KOLBE HOLY BEAR

$ 15.99

Stuffed blue and white bear shows an embroidered picture of St. Maximilian Kolbe. He has the concentration camp jackets and the two crowns. The back of the bear is embroidered with a picture of the back side of the Miraculous Medal with M I.

More Info
Blue plush toy cross.
MY FIRST CROSS BLUE PLUSH
$ 15.99
{ "id":4628921876547, "title":"MY FIRST CROSS BLUE PLUSH","handle":"my-first-cross-blue-plush", "description":"9\" x 6.75\" Light blue plush cross says, \"Love, Sacrifice, Victory, Peace\" on one side. There is a red heart with flames in the center. The other side says, \"My First Cross.\"", "published_at":"2021-01-28T15:05:55", "created_at":"2021-01-28T15:05:55", "vendor":"New Day Christian\/Spiritus", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Baptism","Style_Boy","Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":1599, "price_min":1599, "price_max":1599, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[32295862501443], "variants":[{ "id":32295862501443, "product_id":4628921876547, "product_handle":"my-first-cross-blue-plush", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"975-0587", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"MY FIRST CROSS BLUE PLUSH - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":1599, "weight":60, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":15, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":15, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":""}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/975-0587.jpg?v=1611942367"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/975-0587.jpg?v=1611942367", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/my-first-cross-blue-plush" }
Blue plush toy cross.

MY FIRST CROSS BLUE PLUSH

$ 15.99

9" x 6.75" Light blue plush cross says, "Love, Sacrifice, Victory, Peace" on one side. There is a red heart with flames in the center. The other side says, "My First Cross."

More Info
Pink plush toy cross.
MY FIRST CROSS PINK PLUSH
$ 15.99
{ "id":4628921909315, "title":"MY FIRST CROSS PINK PLUSH","handle":"my-first-cross-pink-plush", "description":"9\" x 6.75\" Light pink plush cross says, \"Love, Sacrifice, Victory, Peace\" on one side. There is a red heart with flames in the center. The other side says, \"My First Cross.\"", "published_at":"2021-01-28T15:05:56", "created_at":"2021-01-28T15:05:56", "vendor":"New Day Christian\/Spiritus", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Baptism","Style_Girl","Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":1599, "price_min":1599, "price_max":1599, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[32295862534211], "variants":[{ "id":32295862534211, "product_id":4628921909315, "product_handle":"my-first-cross-pink-plush", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"975-0586", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"MY FIRST CROSS PINK PLUSH - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":1599, "weight":50, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":17, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":17, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":""}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/975-0586.jpg?v=1611942498"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/975-0586.jpg?v=1611942498", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/my-first-cross-pink-plush" }
Pink plush toy cross.

MY FIRST CROSS PINK PLUSH

$ 15.99

9" x 6.75" Light pink plush cross says, "Love, Sacrifice, Victory, Peace" on one side. There is a red heart with flames in the center. The other side says, "My First Cross."

More Info
8" INSPIRATIONAL LAMB
8" INSPIRATIONAL LAMB
$ 19.99
{ "id":7398154207299, "title":"8\" INSPIRATIONAL LAMB","handle":"8-inspirational-lamb", "description":"The white stuffed lamb is on its knees and has its hooves together in prayer.", "published_at":"2025-04-04T11:08:18", "created_at":"2025-04-04T11:08:18", "vendor":"GANZ", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":1999, "price_min":1999, "price_max":1999, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[42204736421955], "variants":[{ "id":42204736421955, "product_id":7398154207299, "product_handle":"8-inspirational-lamb", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"975-0316", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"8\" INSPIRATIONAL LAMB - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":1999, "weight":150, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":58, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":58, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":null}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he9700_1.png?v=1744223090"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he9700_1.png?v=1744223090", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/8-inspirational-lamb" }
8" INSPIRATIONAL LAMB

8" INSPIRATIONAL LAMB

$ 19.99

The white stuffed lamb is on its knees and has its hooves together in prayer.

More Info
JESUS LOVES ME SACRED LAMB
JESUS LOVES ME SACRED LAMB
$ 24.99
{ "id":7390646173763, "title":"JESUS LOVES ME SACRED LAMB","handle":"jesus-loves-me-sacred-lamb", "description":"UPC: 696322721855\u003cbr\u003eColor: Cream\u003cbr\u003eDimensions: 12\" H.\u003cbr\u003e\u003cbr\u003eLAMB HOLDING WHITE EMBROIDERED CROSS", "published_at":"2025-03-21T14:38:23", "created_at":"2025-03-21T14:38:23", "vendor":"GANZ", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Lent and Easter","Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":2499, "price_min":2499, "price_max":2499, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[42173669933123], "variants":[{ "id":42173669933123, "product_id":7390646173763, "product_handle":"jesus-loves-me-sacred-lamb", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"985-0112", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"JESUS LOVES ME SACRED LAMB - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":2499, "weight":190, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":12, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":12, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":null}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10575_1.png?v=1742828007","\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10575_in_1.png?v=1742828282","\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10575_inb_1.png?v=1742828282"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10575_1.png?v=1742828007", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/jesus-loves-me-sacred-lamb" }
JESUS LOVES ME SACRED LAMB

JESUS LOVES ME SACRED LAMB

$ 24.99

UPC: 696322721855Color: CreamDimensions: 12" H.LAMB HOLDING WHITE EMBROIDERED CROSS

More Info
13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS GIRL 2PC
13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS GIRL 2PC
$ 35.99
{ "id":7390645387331, "title":"13\" LAMB W\/CRIB CROSS GIRL 2PC","handle":"13-lamb-w-crib-cross-girl-2pc", "description":"The white lamb with a pink ribbon has its paws together in prayer. It has an embroidered silver cross on its foot. There is a silver crib cross with pink hearts that shows a girl kneeling and praying. It says, \"Jesus loves me.\"", "published_at":"2025-03-21T14:37:54", "created_at":"2025-03-21T14:37:54", "vendor":"GANZ", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Style_Girl","Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Crib Cross","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":3599, "price_min":3599, "price_max":3599, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[42173668950083], "variants":[{ "id":42173668950083, "product_id":7390645387331, "product_handle":"13-lamb-w-crib-cross-girl-2pc", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"975-0294", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"13\" LAMB W\/CRIB CROSS GIRL 2PC - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":3599, "weight":290, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":33, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":33, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":null}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10233_1.png?v=1742836119","\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10233_htb_1.png?v=1742837029","\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10233_htc_1.png?v=1742837067"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10233_1.png?v=1742836119", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/13-lamb-w-crib-cross-girl-2pc" }
13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS GIRL 2PC

13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS GIRL 2PC

$ 35.99

The white lamb with a pink ribbon has its paws together in prayer. It has an embroidered silver cross on its foot. There is a silver crib cross with pink hearts that shows a girl kneeling and praying. It says, "Jesus loves me."

More Info
13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS BOY 2PC
13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS BOY 2PC
$ 35.99
{ "id":7390645354563, "title":"13\" LAMB W\/CRIB CROSS BOY 2PC","handle":"13-lamb-w-crib-cross-boy-2pc", "description":"White lamb with blue ribbon has its paws together in prayer. It has an embroidered silver cross on its foot. There is a silver crib cross with blue stars that shows a boy kneeling and praying. It says, \"Jesus loves me.\"", "published_at":"2025-03-21T14:37:53", "created_at":"2025-03-21T14:37:53", "vendor":"GANZ", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Style_Boy","Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Crib Cross","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":3599, "price_min":3599, "price_max":3599, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[42173668917315], "variants":[{ "id":42173668917315, "product_id":7390645354563, "product_handle":"13-lamb-w-crib-cross-boy-2pc", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"975-0297", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"13\" LAMB W\/CRIB CROSS BOY 2PC - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":3599, "weight":300, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":37, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":37, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":null}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10234_1.png?v=1742837245"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/he10234_1.png?v=1742837245", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/13-lamb-w-crib-cross-boy-2pc" }
13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS BOY 2PC

13" LAMB W/CRIB CROSS BOY 2PC

$ 35.99

White lamb with blue ribbon has its paws together in prayer. It has an embroidered silver cross on its foot. There is a silver crib cross with blue stars that shows a boy kneeling and praying. It says, "Jesus loves me."

More Info
GODMOTHER BEAR
GODMOTHER BEAR
$ 11.99
{ "id":4521063383107, "title":"GODMOTHER BEAR","handle":"godmother-bear", "description":"Godmother bear is pink and white.It has a light pink ribbon tied in a bow around its neck. It says, \"Godmother\" on the chest. One foot has a cross on it and the other has a clamshell to represent Baptism.", "published_at":"2020-07-22T15:21:52", "created_at":"2020-07-22T15:21:52", "vendor":"Holy Bears, Inc.", "type":"BAPTISM", "tags":["Baptism","Style_Godparent","Style_Stuffed Toys","Type_Toys and Games"], "price":1199, "price_min":1199, "price_max":1199, "price_varies":false, "compare_at_price":null, "compare_at_price_min":0, "compare_at_price_max":0, "compare_at_price_varies":true, "all_variant_ids":[31943726596163], "variants":[{ "id":31943726596163, "product_id":4521063383107, "product_handle":"godmother-bear", "title":"Default Title", "option1":"Default Title", "option2":null, "option3":null, "sku":"975-0009", "requires_shipping":true, "taxable":true, "featured_image":null,"image_id":null, "available":true, "name":"GODMOTHER BEAR - Default Title", "options":["Default Title"], "price":1199, "weight":150, "compare_at_price":null, "inventory_quantity":3, "inventory_management":"shopify", "inventory_policy":"deny", "inventory_in_cart":0, "inventory_remaining":3, "incoming":false, "next_incoming_date":null, "taxable":true, "barcode":""}], "available":true,"images":["\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/975-0009.jpg?v=1595453547"],"featured_image":"\/\/www.marytowngiftshop.com\/cdn\/shop\/products\/975-0009.jpg?v=1595453547", "options":["Title"], "url":"\/products\/godmother-bear" }
GODMOTHER BEAR

GODMOTHER BEAR

$ 11.99

Godmother bear is pink and white.It has a light pink ribbon tied in a bow around its neck. It says, "Godmother" on the chest. One foot has a cross on it and the other has a clamshell to represent Baptism.

More Info
Filter Products
Type
Subject
Color
Size
Style